Skip to Content

7 Best Poblano Pepper Substitutes

This article may contain affiliate links and if you make a purchase after clicking on a link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Do you want to add some variety to your home-cooked meals? Get acquainted with poblano peppers! Poblano peppers, which originated in Puebla, Mexico, have achieved international recognition due to the growing popularity of Mexican cuisine.

This massive and luxuriant dark green, nearly black chile is prized for its oaky and full-bodied flavor, as well as its slightly spicy flavoring.

Because of its low concentrations of spice and sweet taste, this cherished pepper can be barbecued and consumed whole or packed with meat and cheese to add just about the appropriate balance of kick to your meal.

And if for any reason you do not have it at home, you can use other poblano pepper substitutes, such as cayenne pepper, Anaheim pepper, New Mexico chiles, bell pepper, guajillo peppers, jalapeno pepper, and ancho chilies, to add flavor to your dishes.

What to Consider When Getting a Poblano Pepper Replacement

Regardless of the commonalities, even the greatest poblano pepper replacement may not suit your taste. When it comes to individual taste, this is often a matter of trial and error.

Once searching for a substitute for poblano pepper, consider this:

  • Threshold of spice: Not everybody can manage the temperature of peppery peppers. Poblanos are still comparatively mild peppers, but many options available may have a higher Scoville rating. Using the wrong type or fraction of pepper in a dish can ruin your meal. On the other hand, excessive spiciness may cause tummy ache as well as other intestinal problems.
  • Physical properties: Are you searching for a pepper that can occupy a hole? Maybe something to add a little zing to your dish? Large chilies with thick walls are suitable for filling recipes, whereas smaller peppers are best for preparing sauces or garnishes.
  • The dish category is directly related to the pepper’s features. When looking at alternatives to poblano peppers, it’s best to keep the category of food you would like to plan in mind. Not all peppers, for example, are suitable for slicing or dicing. Some are only intended for salsa recipes or sprinkled on top of food.

Best Poblano Pepper Substitutes

But consider this. You walk into your kitchen, all set to make a hearty dish of laced poblano peppers with chicken as well as cheese, when you come to realize you’re missing a crucial component.

Maintain your horses before you hurry back to the supermarket. Fortunately, the spicy pepper family is relatively large, so you may always have a viable replacement in your fridge or freezer.

1. Anaheim pepper

If you’re searching for a good poblano pepper direct replacement, look no further. Anaheim peppers, which have a strong resemblance and structure to poblanos, could be used similarly.

Even though this spicy pepper is native to New Mexico, it was named after Anaheim, California. Anaheim peppers have thick walls that are ideal for supporting stuffed pepper dishes, and they are also similar in width to their spicy cousin.

However, Anaheim peppers are the best replacements when cut up, sliced, or finely chopped and introduced to a salad, soup, or stew. Consult your kitchen cupboard for Anaheim peppers if you don’t have any on hand. This adaptable chile is also available in powder form.

2. Cayenne Peppers

Cayenne peppers come next. These spicy peppers, which originated in Central and South America, are too long and skinny to be included in encrusted meals.

Their savory, peppery seasoning, on the other hand, is nearly identical to that of poblanos, making it an excellent seasoning swap. Cayenne pepper is a spice that you’re probably most familiar with and have on hand in your spice rack.

Cayenne peppers are typically used dry or as granules to add a spicy kick to a dish. The greatest feature about this standby component is that replacing it is a piece of cake.

3. Guajillo Chilies

Guajillo peppers, like poblano peppers, are distinctive to Mexican cuisine and have gone mainstream over time. These peppers are best used in sauces and salsas because of their streamlined, dark red surface and rich flavor.

 They will start by taking any pastry dish or stir fry to another level with their intensely flavorful flavor.  Unlike most other peppers on this page, Guajillo peppers are most mainly encountered dry, pelletized, or paste.

 So, if you’re in a pinch, make sure to check your pantry for Guajillo varieties! Guajillo peppers have the same heat levels as jalapenos, making them spicier than poblanos.

4. New Mexico Chilies

New Mexico chiles are an excellent substitute for poblano peppers. These hot peppers have a rich, rustic, and verdant taste with a moderate quantity of spice, comparable to the poblano.

If you’ve chosen this replacement for your dish, you don’t have to be concerned about the peppers providing far too much heat, but you should anticipate and start preparing for a distinct taste profile.

This pepper, which is most frequently used in red stews, is ideal for baked products, soups, stews, sauces, and stir-fries. Green New Mexico chilies, which have a comparable crunchy and brittle texture to garlic and onions, make an excellent replacement.

5. Bell Peppers

Bell peppers are a safe bet as a replacement for poblanos when you already have them on hand. Bell peppers and poblanos are very comparable in size and visual appeal.

With its thick walls and large porosities, this type is ideal for a filled pepper dish. If you have a plethora of bells in your fridge, go for the green diverse selection. Green bell peppers have a fuller, more flavorful taste, whereas yellow, red, and orange bell peppers are tastier.

Poblano and bell peppers are, at best, relatives when it tends to come to spice. Bell peppers are much milder, but some would argue that they are devoid of spice.

6. Ancho Chilies

Finally, Ancho chiles are excellent replacements for poblano peppers. This sweet and tangy pepper is merely a dried poblano and is a perfect substitute for finely chopped poblano peppers in recipes that call for them.

Despite their similarity, Ancho chilies, as well as poblano peppers, have very different flavor profiles. Ancho chilies have a smokey, leafier flavor than fresh pepper substitutes because they are dried. Furthermore, when it comes to temperature, Ancho chilies are far milder.

When using this substitute, restrict the amount of Ancho chilies you use in your meal. To begin, do not add too many peppers to your dish; owing to the variation in taste between such main ingredients, you’ll want to taste test and make adjustments.

The most crucial component of using such a backup component is that it should be juiced before use.

7. Jalapeno peppers

If you are looking for a stand-in that packs a powerful punch? Try the jalapeno pepper, which is small but mighty.

However, don’t be duped by appearances; while jalapenos resemble chili peppers, they are still suitable for use in filling recipe ideas. Remember that jalapenos are much smaller peppers, whereas poblanos resemble the larger bell pepper variation.

Ideal for salads, salsas, or sauces, poblanos are no competition for the hot and spicy jalapeno when it comes to bringing the heat, so if you’re searching for more temperature, this is good power.

If you want to reduce the temperature in your dish, remove the grooves and pits of the jalapenos before actually integrating them.

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I use in place of poblano peppers?

Poblano peppers can be substituted with bell peppers. They resemble Jalapeos in exterior but lack some of the oaky flavors of Poblanos. They still have a similar flavor, but they are relatively mild than Poblanos.

Is a poblano pepper like a jalapeno?

The poblano pepper is a gentle to intermediate pepper with a Scoville rating of 1,000 to 2,000. They are warmer than banana peppers, but it’s not as peppery as jalapeno peppers, with a Scoville heat unit range of 2,500 to 8,000.

What is the flavor of poblano?

Poblanos are usually sold green and underripe, which makes them exceptionally gentle. They have a flavor comparable to a green bell pepper but with more kick. Cooking this pepper, soften them even more and turn them mildly sweet. Also, mature poblanos are red and have a spicier flavor than underripe green peppers.

Are poblano peppers hot?

The poblano, which is enormous and heart-shaped, is commonly used in Mexican dishes such as chiles Rellenos. Are poblano peppers hot? Yes, but only in a mildly spicy way. When mature, the poblano tends to turn a dark red-brown color and can be left to dry, at which point it is known as an ancho or mulato.

Is Anaheim a poblano pepper?

Anaheim peppers, like poblanos, are typically moderately hot but can amaze with heat every once in a while. They are more sensitive than poblanos, with a narrow form and a milder color. They are often barbecued and scraped before use, like poblanos, but they can also be utilized fresh.

Conclusion

Peppers are a fine replacement for poblanos because they add a new depth to any dish by adding deliciousness without detracting from the taste profile.

Use caution when substituting spicier ingredients, or you may eventually wind up with an unforeseen flavor profile for your meal!