5 Best Yum Yum Sauce Substitutes

Posted on

Yum Yum Sauce Substitutes



Prep time

Cooking time

Total time


This article may contain affiliate links and if you make a purchase after clicking on a link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

I love Yum Yum Sauce, it’s a wonderful ingredient that will always add premium taste and flavor to your dishes. Sadly, it’s usually difficult to find them in stores when I need them.

And I know that plenty people are also facing this problem, which is why I’ll be discussing some of the best yum yum sauce substitutes, such as Fry sauce, Thai Peanut Sauce, Tzatziki, Ponzu, Hollandaise sauce, Harissa sauce, and Chipotle mayo.

These alternatives will also be great on your plate of chicken, rice, fried rice, shrimp, and broccoli.

Let’s quickly learn more about them!

What Is Yum Yum Sauce?

Yum Yum Sauce is a blend of mayonnaise, tomato paste, melted butter, garlic powder, and paprika.

It has a bright pink color and a creamy texture. Most people describe it as having a savory, creamy flavor with a hint of sweetness.

The sauce is commonly served with Japanese food, including hibachi chicken and shrimp. Some restaurants use the sauce as a dip for French fries.

Best Yum Yum Sauce Substitutes

1. Fry Sauce

They might appear similar sauces, but they are actually two very different condiments. Fry sauce is a Utah-born concoction that combines mayonnaise and ketchup.

Yum yum sauce is a Japanese condiment with a similar flavor profile, but it uses rice vinegar instead of ketchup and is generally sweeter than fry sauce.

So YES, fry sauce and yum yum sauce is interchangeable! You can dip your fries in fry sauce and your chicken strips in yum yum sauce. It’ll still taste GREAT.

Haters will say that yum yum sauce is different from fry sauce due to the tomato paste and paprika, but they’re wrong. Fry sauce is just as delicious as yum yum sauce, even if it doesn’t have paprika and tomato paste.

2. Thai Peanut Sauce

Thai peanut sauce is made from crushed peanuts and served over noodles or rice dishes.

It has the peanut flavor that its name promises, but it also contains coconut milk, garlic, cilantro, chili peppers (which give it some heat), fish sauce (which provides saltiness), and lime juice (for acidity).

It is a suitable alternative for yum yum sauce, although its essential ingredients give it a sweeter taste and lighter body than the thick consistency of Thai peanut sauce.

3. Tzatziki

There is no doubt that tzatziki sauce is delicious. It is a Greek sauce made with yogurt, cucumbers, garlic, lemon juice, salt, and dill. Tzatziki is commonly served with grilled meat or a dip with pita bread or vegetables.

And it will make an excellent substitute for yum yum sauce, adding a healthy twist to your favorite recipe. You can use it on various foods, including chicken, fish, and vegetables.

4. Hollandaise Sauce

Hollandaise Sauce is a suitable alternative for yum yum sauce because they have similar ingredients.

They are both creamy and white, but Hollandaise sauce is a thick sauce that is perfect for your seafood or eggs. While Yum yum sauce has a thinner consistency, both sauces are used as dipping sauces and served cold.

You can eat Hollandaise Sauce with Eggs Benedict, poached eggs, broccoli, asparagus, potatoes, etc.

5. Chipotle Mayo

You don’t have any yum yum sauce, and you don’t feel like going to the store. Luckily, if you have Chipotle Mayo on hand, you can use that instead.

While there are other alternatives to yum yum sauce, they don’t compare to the unique flavor profile of chipotle mayo.

Chipotle mayo is a suitable alternative for yum yum sauce because it has many same ingredients. Most Japanese steakhouse chefs say that their secret ingredient is chipotle mayo!

The difference between chipotle mayo and yum yum sauce is that chipotle mayo has an added layer of spice, thanks to the chipotle mayo peppers themselves.

Related Questions

What is Japanese Mayo Used For?

Japanese mayonnaise is an incredibly versatile condiment. Here are a couple of ways to use it:  

  • As a dip for french fries
  • Used to replace milk for scrambled eggs
  • As a base for your homemade mayonnaise (add extra egg yolks and salt)
  • Used in creamy salad dressing

Where Is Yum Yum Sauce From?

Yum yum sauce is from Miyazaki, Japan.

Is There MSG In Yum Yum Sauce?

No. Yum yum sauce doesn’t contain any MSG! Although it’s hard to pin down an exact recipe, most versions of yum yum sauce include mayonnaise, ketchup, water, vinegar, sugar, paprika, garlic powder, and onion powder — none of those ingredients contain MSG.

What Are The Benefits Of Eating Yum Yum Sauce

Eating yum yum sauce allows you to improve your intake of certain nutrients essential for your health. It’s also possible to consume the sauce in moderation and get its benefits without consuming too many calories or fats.

The following are some of the most important benefits of eating yum yum sauce.

  1. Yum yum sauce can help you meet your calcium needs for the day
  2. Yum yum sauce is a source of vitamin D
  3. Yum yum sauce contains potassium
  4. Yum yum sauce may help prevent macular degeneration
  5. Yummy Sauce contains vitamin K2

What Is The Best Way To Eat Yum Yum Sauce

With Yum-Yum Sauce, the possibilities are endless. Here are just a few ways you can enjoy this delectable treat:

  • On chicken
  • On shrimp
  • On steak
  • On vegetables
  • Directly into your mouth


Okay, so I’m biased because I like the yum yum sauce so much. This is the only reason I am incapable of finding a suitable substitute.

I have tried many, but I always come back to the original.

I’m not too fond of it when companies mess with already perfect recipes and ruin them due to greed.

So watch out!

You may also want to read:


You might also like these recipes