Skip to Content

Top 5 Helpful Substitutes for Shiitake Mushrooms (+ IMAGES)

This article may contain affiliate links and if you make a purchase after clicking on a link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Unlike some mushrooms, the shiitake mushroom is tasty as well as healthy. It is an excellent source of natural copper with stronger bones, blood vessel, and general immunity.

In addition to their salivary taste and earthly aroma, they are also low in calories, high in fiber, and contain B vitamins.

It is notorious for its ability to help in weight loss. Shiitake mushroom can be cooked with ramen, soup, pasta, steak, or stirred fried with or without oil.

They are a safe option for both omnivores and vegetarians, as they can serve as meat since they contain the same level of amino acid. Porcini, which is a more popular option, can be used as a alternative for shiitake mushrooms.

Some other popular substitutes for shiitake mushrooms are Crimini and oyster mushroom.

What is Shiitake Mushroom?

Substitutes for Shiitake Mushrooms

Shiitake mushrooms are dark brown edible mushrooms native to East Asia. They could be sold or stored in dried or fresh forms and are used as dietary supplements sometimes.

It is advisable to cook the shiitake mushroom thoroughly before eating.

Substitutes For Shiitake Mushrooms

Shiitake mushrooms are native to East Asia, so they are usually in their dried form to preserve. Nonetheless, they are still scarce in certain states or communities.

In situations such as this, a substitute for shiitake mushroom is essential. Some of these substitutes include:

1. Portobello Mushroom

Portobello Mushroom

These mushrooms are a safe option for vegetarians who use them to substitute meat. They are usually cooked and eat with soups, gravy, pizza, hamburgers, etc., just like shiitake mushrooms.

They also have the earthy taste of shiitake mushrooms, as well as the chewy and meaty features. They are brown in color and firm in texture.

Just like the shiitake mushroom, you should cook them extensively.

2. Porcini Mushrooms

Porcini Mushrooms

They are more nutty than earthy in flavor. But this does not take away the delicious taste of porcini mushroom. Just like the shiitake mushroom, it is very chewy and meat-like.

Because of their complexity, porcini mushrooms are not easy to cultivate. As such, they are a little expensive.

The upside is that you can buy them in bulk and store them, as the porcini mushroom never spoils or loses its taste.

3. Crimini Mushrooms

Crimini Mushrooms

You can refer to them as the younger brothers of portobello mushroom or baby Bella. Crimini mushrooms have a smooth rounded cap and are often dark brown.

Easily accessible, you can buy crimini mushrooms at grocery stores. They are also affordable.

4. Oyster Mushrooms

Oyster Mushrooms

Just like shiitake mushrooms, you can grill, fry or roast an oyster mushroom. The oyster mushroom is part of a big family, and as such, there are different types.

They come in different sizes. The biggest one is known as King Oyster Mushroom.

5. Dried Shiitake Mushroom in place of the fresh one

Due to the nativity and unavailability of shiitake mushroom, it is preserved in dried form. Even though the fresh shiitake mushroom is juicy, it doesn’t, however, have a strong taste like the dried ones.

You can see serve the Shiitake Mushrooms and the substitutes for Shiitake Mushroom in the following way:

  • Stir-fried with Green Beans
  • Crunch and crispy Sesame
  • Mushroom soup
  • Stuffed with Tofu, spring onions, etc.
  • Sauteed with butter, pepper, and salt

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you eat all the shiitake mushrooms?

All parts of shiitake mushrooms, including the stalk, are edible. It is also safe to eat the shiitake mushroom raw, even though it is almost impossible since it is usually dried. Because it is fibrous and chewy, the stalk of shiitake mushroom feels like meat.

How does Shiitake Mushrooms taste?

Remember the waft of fresh in the morning after it had rained at night; that is how eating shiitake mushroom feels.

Our sense of taste comes from smell, so maybe that will give you a hint. The delicious mushroom has a robust buttery-earthy taste that elevates the quality of every meal it graces.

Are Shiitake mushrooms good on pizza?

If you are a mushroom lover, then you probably pick mushrooms as a topping. Shiitake mushrooms are an excellent choice for pizza topping.

Shiitake mushrooms are not only great on pizza, but they also complement the round baked dough with its savory, earthy taste. The shiitake mushroom goes great with tomatoes, cheese, and beef.

Are Shiitake and Portobello Mushrooms the same?

Portobellos are large meaty mushrooms native to North America and Europe. They are usually really fleshy and meaty — Portobello mushrooms are alternatives for meat in hamburgers.

In comparison, shiitake mushrooms are native to East Asia and used in most Chinese and Japanese cuisine.

The most crucial difference between the two types of mushrooms lies in their nutritional value. While the portobello is rich in vitamin D, Iron, and potassium, it does not rank as high as shiitake mushrooms.

Shiitake mushrooms are rich in polysaccharides. They help with cell damage, cell production and generally boosting the immune system.

Are Shiitake Mushrooms good for weight loss?

Shiitake mushrooms contain high amounts of hypolipidemic, which has fat-reducing properties such as eritadenine and b-glucan.

They are an excellent meat substitute and are excellent sources of protein and fiber. Because of their chewy nature, they enable persons to eat slowly, thereby consuming less food for an extended period.

It also contains vitamin B, which helps gives agility and sustenance throughout the day.

Related Posts:

Conclusion | What Can I Use Instead Of Shiitake Mushrooms?

It is difficult for people to cultivate shiitake mushrooms in several parts of the world. As a result of this, there is a need for substitutes for shiitake mushrooms.

Some of the mushrooms are more available, like the crimini mushroom. Most of them have the same earthy taste as shiitake mushrooms.

And are also chewy and meaty, like shiitake mushroom. You can take your pick from the substitute of shiitake mushroom listed above.