Nilla Wafers Vs Ladyfingers: Key Differences

This article may contain affiliate links and if you make a purchase after clicking on a link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Nilla wafers and ladyfingers are two sweet cookies that you commonly find in the shopping aisles of most grocery stores. Both are small, circular, and taste good when paired with ice cream or whipped topping. These cookies can be served as a sweet dessert if you have guests over.

Now, the question is: what’s the difference between Nilla Wafers vs Ladyfingers? How do they taste? Is one better than the other?

Ladyfinger has a delicate taste matched by a few cookies in the world. Nilla Wafers, on the other hand, are lighter and fluffier than Ladyfinger, whose texture is more like that of tortilla chips with shorter baking times.

But that’s not all there is!

Also, the rest of the questions will be answered below to find which one is best for your taste buds.

What are Nilla Wafers?

Nilla Wafers are a sweet, vanilla-flavored cookies. You can eat them independently or use them in recipes to create different flavors and textures.

It’s the perfect balance of crunchy, sweet, and creamy rolled into one perfectly delicious bite.

They are made with flour, sugar, butter, and eggs. The batter is then baked into thin wafers with browned edges for a crispy snack that kids and adults love!

Is your sweet tooth tingling?

Then Nilla Wafers are the perfect treat!

They will help keep you going on all your biggest adventures.

But they also pair perfectly with milk for a fantastic snack for any time of day or night — and great for dipping!

You can use it to decorate cakes and cupcakes, in banana pudding, Raspberry Cream Pie, etc.

See Also: Baking Cocoa Vs Cocoa Powder

What are Ladyfingers?

A friend of mine, a chef, described Ladyfingers as a finger that tastes like a lady.

That’s so funny!

Ladyfinger is a crisp sponge cake with a delicate taste and dense texture, making it great for absorbing liquids without becoming too soggy or falling apart.

Also Ladyfinger is an inch wide and about three inches long. This lady is the heart and soul for making tiramisu, an Italian dessert.

Although, you can be used in many different dishes and desserts.

You can use them as a garnish, dip them in coffee or tea or top them with whipped cream and fruit.

You can even fill them with custard or caramel for an extra sweet treat.

The possibilities are endless!

Many of the world’s top chefs have been and are still using Ladyfingers in their dishes.

Nilla Wafers Vs Ladyfingers

So what are the key differences between Nilla Wafers Vs Ladyfingers

It’s a question that has been debated for many years, but hopefully, the information below finally provides some clarity.

Key DifferenceNilla WafersLadyfingers
AppearanceNilla Wafers are short, flat, rounded, and crunchyLadyfingers are long, spongy, and soft
Tastetaste like sugar, vanilla, and wheat.Slightly sweet taste.
Ingredientflour, sugar, shortening, and eggs.Eggs, sugar Salt, vanilla extract all-purpose flour, and cornstarch  

Aside from that, I know you must be wondering what the best way to enjoy these cookies is?

Nilla Wafers taste great on their own or dipped in milk or your favorite hot beverage. They can also be used as a crunchy topping for ice cream or pie crust.

Ladyfingers tend to be too delicate to stand up to any dunking, but they’re perfect for making trifles or tiramisu.

So if you’re looking for a cookie that can handle a little dunking action and is friendly to vegans and vegetarians, go for Nilla Wafers!

If you’re more interested in using cookies as an ingredient in another dish like tiramisu or trifle, reach for Ladyfingers instead!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Substitute Nilla Wafers For Ladyfingers?

The short answer is yes, but I’ll explain why it’s better to use ladyfingers. You can substitute Nilla wafers for ladyfingers because they have similar texture and consistency. But there are things you need to put into perspective.

Nilla wafers are crisper than ladyfingers. They won’t absorb liquid as readily if you’re using them as part of a dessert, such as tiramisu or Zuppa inglese. That could change the taste and texture of your finished product.

Nilla wafers are smaller than ladyfingers, making it difficult to use them in recipes where you need more than one cookie per layer (such as tiramisu).

What Can Be Substituted For Ladyfingers In Tiramisu?

Fear not if you want to make tiramisu, but you don’t have ladyfingers on hand! You have lots of options to choose from.

Here are the best alternatives:

  • A sponge cake
  • Graham crackers
  • Biscotti
  • Angel food cake

Does Nabisco Still Make Vanilla Wafers?

Yes, Nabisco still makes vanilla wafers. The company produces them on its line of single-serving packages for the convenience market. Still, it does not continue to sell them in the original bulk packaging due to a lack of popularity.

Nabisco originated in 1898 as a merger between two companies that owned bakeries. It has gone through several name changes and ownership transfers since then. Today it is owned by the multinational food and beverage company Mondelez International.

What Can I Use Instead Of Vanilla Wafers In Banana Pudding?

We found that graham crackers, butter cookies, and shortbread are excellent substitutes for vanilla wafers in banana pudding. They have a similar texture and flavor, and they mix well with the bananas to create a pudding that’s as good as the original version.

We recommend breaking up the graham crackers into smaller pieces for best results before adding them to the pudding.

See Also: Liquid Aminos Vs Coconut Aminos


Overall, Nilla Wafers vs Ladyfingers are not that different. However, the Nilla Wafers crisp up while baking while the ladyfingers do not. The question which should matter to you is whether this makes a difference to your dessert.

If you do not care about the look, then ladyfingers would serve you right, but if appearance matters, try Nilla wafers out instead. I hope this has helped you figure out which one is perfect for your cravings.

There is no hard and fast rule to decide whether one is better than the other; it depends on what you like more.