9 Best Crème De Cacao Substitutes

This article may contain affiliate links and if you make a purchase after clicking on a link, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Let us face it; there is nothing quite like chocolate when it comes to a sweet treat. It is rich, creamy, and leaves you wanting more like Crème De Cacao. But what if there was a way to take chocolate to the next level?

You might consider using a chocolate liqueur, firelit coffee liqueur, mozart chocolate spirit, chocolate extract, kahlua, chocolate powder, baileys chocolat luxe, cholocate syrup, or even opt for homemade creme de cacao.

There are all fantastic Crème De Cacao Substitutes that are readily available and affordable, and we will be discussing them on this page.

Let us quickly check them out!

What is Crème De Cacao?

Crème De Cacao is a sweet, chocolate-flavored liqueur used in many desserts and cocktails.

It is a versatile ingredient that can be used to flavor everything from cakes to ice cream, and it can also be used to create cocktails that range from martinis milkshake-like treats to dry after-dinner sips like the White Russian.

Furthermore, it is made from cocoa beans, sugar, and vanilla and comes in both clear and brown varieties. Crème de Cacao also pairs well with Chambord, Kahlua, vodka, and whiskey.

Best Crème De Cacao Substitutes

It would be best if you used a substitute for Crème De Cacao because no one wants to drink Crème De Cacao by itself. Crème De Cacao is pretty gross. It is chocolate-flavored booze, and who wants that?

You are better off using a substitute that does not just taste like booze; everyone has to pretend they like it.

1. Kahlua

Kahlua is a coffee liqueur. Creme de cacao is a chocolate liqueur, and they are two popular choices for mixing into after-dinner cocktails. They are both sweet and versatile enough to be used in many different cocktails. However, they are not the same, yet you can swap one for another.

It is a tried-and-true brand that stands out among the rest. You can drink neat or on ice; and make cocktails. Bakers use it when making desserts, cakes, and cheesecakes, top on ice cream.

Additionally, Kahlua pairs well with milk, coffee, cream, and cocoa.

See Also: Best Substitutes for Brandy

2. Chocolate Liqueur

Many people think crème de cacao and chocolate liqueur are the same, but they are not. They only have similar flavors.

Moreover, there are many good reasons to use chocolate liqueur instead of crème de cacao when you need a chocolate flavor in your cocktail.

For starters, it is made with real chocolate. Crème de cacao is often made with artificial chocolate flavoring that can taste and smell distinctly fake.

In addition, the Chocolate liqueur is usually creamier than crème de cacao because it has a lower alcohol content to make the silky cocktail smooth.

Unless your recipe specifically calls for crème de cacao, there are a few reasons not to replace it with chocolate liqueur.

3. Firelit Coffee Liqueur

Another great substitute for Creme de Cacao is Firelit coffee liqueur. While there are a few options for substituting for crème de cacao, Firelit coffee liqueur is typically the best choice.

Firelit coffee liqueur has all the qualities of crème de cacao, but with an extra kick of caffeine to make sure you are wide awake when you are out on the town.

Whether you are trying to recreate a recipe that calls for Creme de Cacao, have some faith in Firelit coffee liqueur. It has a high quality, silky-smooth, and sweet chocolate flavor that adds a unique depth to all of your Creme De Cacao needs.

4. Mozart Chocolate Spirit

You should use Mozart Chocolate Spirit instead of Creme de Cacao for the best results. Mozart Chocolate Spirit is made from the best cacao and caramel, which gives it a much richer flavor profile than other liqueurs.

Its unique recipe makes it versatile in cocktails and as an ingredient in desserts. In addition to its great taste, Mozart Chocolate Spirit can be added to various recipes without overpowering the other flavors.

This is because it has a lower alcohol content than Creme de Cacao and will not affect the outcome of your dish (unless you add too much).

Mozart Chocolate Spirit also adds sweetness without sugar or artificial sweeteners, so you do not have to worry about ruining your healthy eating plan.

See Also: Top 9 Most Famous Belgian Beers

5. Baileys Chocolat Luxe

Baileys Chocolat Luxe is a cheaper alternative to Creme De Cacao. Baileys Chocolat Luxe contains the same amount of chocolate and vanilla. However, the difference is that Baileys Chocolat Luxe contains less alcoholic content of about 15%.

Whereas Creme De Cacao is 20%, making it easier to drink without alcohol intoxication occurring as quickly.

This makes Baileys Chocolat Luxe a more approachable option if you are looking for something sweet and subtle to sip on instead of a full-bodied cocktail.

6. Chocolate Extract

While Creme De Cacao is an alcohol-based product often used to make cocktails and drinks, it is a bit of a pain to find, especially if you do not live near a liquor store.

In addition, if you do find it, it is probably not particularly cheap.

On the other hand, Chocolate extract is a less expensive and more convenient way to get the flavor of dark chocolate into your baked goods, smoothies, and other recipes.

Aside from that, it is made with natural ingredients and can be found at most grocery stores.

7. Chocolate Powder

Ah, the age-old debate: Chocolate powder vs. Creme De Cacao. It is tough, but luckily we have all the hot tips right here.

Chocolate powder is used in everything from chocolate milk, to smoothies, to frostings. It is a great alternative to have on hand when you want something that’s not too sweet, and has a rich chocolate flavor.

Creme de Cacao is a liqueur with a strong vanilla flavor and is sweeter than chocolate powder. It can be added to cocktails for extra flavor or topping for ice cream or pudding.

Nevertheless, there are many reasons to use chocolate powder instead of Creme De Cacao when making a dessert.

First, it is much cheaper than purchasing the crème de cacao. It is also much easier to use—because it is a powder, you do not have to worry about measuring it out correctly or adding too much or too little to your recipe.

The chocolate powder has a richer flavor and a smoother texture, so your dessert will be more enjoyable for everyone who eats it.

8. Chocolate Syrup

Chocolate syrup is an excellent replacement for Creme De Cacao when you need to add chocolate flavor to a drink but do not want it to be alcoholic.

Chocolate syrup is a thicker liquid and has higher sugar content. Using chocolate syrup instead of crème de cacao can change your drink’s texture, consistency, and alcohol content. However, they both taste delicious. You can use either topping or dessert sauce for various desserts.

It also goes well when blended with milk and ice cream for a milkshake.

9. Homemade Creme De Cacao

If you are not impressed by Creme De Cacao flavor, it is high time you made yours. The advantage of homemade is that many of the most popular brands at liquor stores are made from artificial flavors and have tons of added sugar.

Luckily, it is easy to make a natural Homemade Creme De Cacao.

You need cacao nibs and neutral liquor like vodka or gin.

Homemade Creme De Cacao also has much less sugar than store-bought varieties, so you can make cocktails that are less sweet but still have the rich flavor you’re looking for. And it is straightforward!

All you need is a little bit of time and some inexpensive ingredients. Here is how to do it

You will need:

  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 cup water
  • One vanilla bean
  • 3 cups cacao nibs or chopped unsweetened chocolate
  • 2 cups vodka (or rum)

1. Mix the water and sugar in a saucepan over medium heat until the sugar dissolves. Bring to vanilla bean to simmer after adding them up. Bring it down and let it cool.

2. Put the cacao nibs or chopped chocolate in a large bowl, then pour the cooled syrup over them. Let this steep for 8-12 hours or overnight.

Strain the mixture through cheesecloth or a fine-mesh strainer into another bowl, and then squeeze out any remaining liquid from the solids with your hands.

Discard the solids and store the liquid in an airtight container in your refrigerator for up to 3days before use.

See Also: Best Substitutes For Cognac

Frequently asked questions

Is there a Difference between Brown and White Creme De Cacao?

The main difference between white and brown crème de cacao is color. However, if you are making a drink with several other ingredients, you might consider using one over the other for continuity in your final product.

For example, if you are making a layered drink like a B-52 and want all the layers to be different shades of brown, it would make sense to use brown crème de cacao instead of white. Color also plays into your choice if you are making a drink that will be heavily garnished with whipped cream or ice cream.

A white crème de cacao will disappear into that garnish, but a brown one will stand out more prominently against the lighter color. In addition, White crème de cacao has a much less intense flavor than brown crème de cacao.

It is sweeter, with hints of vanilla and chocolate, while brown crème de cacao has a more bitter and robust chocolate taste.

What Is The Flavor Of Creme De Cacao?

Creme de cacao tastes like chocolate heaven. The word “crème” means cream, so when you are saying “crème de cacao,” you are saying “cream of chocolate.” The flavor of crème de cacao is sweet, rich, and chocolatey — everything that a drink based on chocolate should be.

A little bit goes a long way, providing a full-bodied experience with each sip.

Does Kahlua Have Caffeine?

Yes, Kahlua does have caffeine. Kahlua is coffee-based, meaning that it is made with coffee beans.

This coffee bean base contains varying levels of caffeine per serving: for a 100mL serving (or about 3/4 cup), there are between 12 and 35 milligrams of caffeine — a relatively large range. Hence, it is hard to say precisely how much caffeine you will get from one serving.

 Kahlua also contains rum, which naturally contains no caffeine.

Why Is It Called Kahlua?

Kahlua is a coffee-flavored liqueur that is made in Veracruz, Mexico. Kahlua is derived from the Nahuatl word “caluha,” which means “stirred up.” Looking at the root term, Kahlua got its name from the way it is stirred.

 The base ingredients are sugar and coffee mixed with water and vanilla beans.

Conclusion

Hopefully, our list of best Crème De Cacao substitutes help you miss Crème De Cacao less whenever it’s outside your reach.

I am positive the Kahlua, Baileys Chocolat Luxe, or Firelit Coffee Liqueur can satisfy your taste buds.

Nevertheless, if you really cannot live without Crème De Cacao, you can choose to make it yourself. You can find the necessary ingredient and instructions on whipping it up.

Scroll to Top